A systematic approach to identifying key parameters and processes in agroecosystem models

V Myrgiotis, RM Rees, CFE Topp, M Williams

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
4 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Process-based agroecosystem biogeochemistry models are widely used to quantify the flow of water and nutrients in agricultural ecosystems and they have become important tools in the effort to address the twin challenges of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving agricultural sustainability. Model parameters require careful calibration, as they affect the simulated processes and outputs. Sensitivity analysis (SA) is commonly used to quantify the impacts of parameters on outputs, and guide the calibration process. Here we demonstrate a systematic approach for SA, which assures that (1) the role of time-dependency in the sensitivity indices is considered and (2) the SA is not biased by the edapho-climatic conditions at individual sites. Demonstrating this approach, we examine the parametric sensitivity of an advanced agroecosystem model (Landscape-DNDC) using a framework that is based on (1) the Sobol SA method, (2) model simulations at three UK arable sites and (3) the grouping of the model's parameters according to the processes they affect. The findings of this research identify the parameters and processes that should be carefully examined in order to minimise the impact of parametric uncertainty on model outputs. We show that a limited number of parameters are responsible for a large part of the sensitivity of model outputs. The description of soil microbial dynamics is identified as a key source of output sensitivity. Also, we show that individual management activities can significantly affect the time-dependency of the parametric sensitivity indices for certain model outputs.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)344 - 356
Number of pages13
JournalEcological Modelling
Volume368
Early online date26 Dec 2017
DOIs
Publication statusFirst published - 26 Dec 2017

Fingerprint

agricultural ecosystem
sensitivity analysis
calibration
parameter
alternative agriculture
biogeochemistry
greenhouse gas
nutrient
simulation

Bibliographical note

1023324
1024888
1030795

Keywords

  • Ecosystem modelling
  • Landscape-DNDC
  • Sensitivity analysis
  • Soil biogeochemistry

Cite this

@article{71f78a772ffc4045b2678b7b75abae71,
title = "A systematic approach to identifying key parameters and processes in agroecosystem models",
abstract = "Process-based agroecosystem biogeochemistry models are widely used to quantify the flow of water and nutrients in agricultural ecosystems and they have become important tools in the effort to address the twin challenges of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving agricultural sustainability. Model parameters require careful calibration, as they affect the simulated processes and outputs. Sensitivity analysis (SA) is commonly used to quantify the impacts of parameters on outputs, and guide the calibration process. Here we demonstrate a systematic approach for SA, which assures that (1) the role of time-dependency in the sensitivity indices is considered and (2) the SA is not biased by the edapho-climatic conditions at individual sites. Demonstrating this approach, we examine the parametric sensitivity of an advanced agroecosystem model (Landscape-DNDC) using a framework that is based on (1) the Sobol SA method, (2) model simulations at three UK arable sites and (3) the grouping of the model's parameters according to the processes they affect. The findings of this research identify the parameters and processes that should be carefully examined in order to minimise the impact of parametric uncertainty on model outputs. We show that a limited number of parameters are responsible for a large part of the sensitivity of model outputs. The description of soil microbial dynamics is identified as a key source of output sensitivity. Also, we show that individual management activities can significantly affect the time-dependency of the parametric sensitivity indices for certain model outputs.",
keywords = "Ecosystem modelling, Landscape-DNDC, Sensitivity analysis, Soil biogeochemistry",
author = "V Myrgiotis and RM Rees and CFE Topp and M Williams",
note = "1023324 1024888 1030795",
year = "2017",
month = "12",
day = "26",
doi = "10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2017.12.009",
language = "English",
volume = "368",
pages = "344 -- 356",
journal = "Ecological Modelling",
issn = "0304-3800",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

A systematic approach to identifying key parameters and processes in agroecosystem models. / Myrgiotis, V; Rees, RM; Topp, CFE; Williams, M.

In: Ecological Modelling, Vol. 368, 26.12.2017, p. 344 - 356.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - A systematic approach to identifying key parameters and processes in agroecosystem models

AU - Myrgiotis, V

AU - Rees, RM

AU - Topp, CFE

AU - Williams, M

N1 - 1023324 1024888 1030795

PY - 2017/12/26

Y1 - 2017/12/26

N2 - Process-based agroecosystem biogeochemistry models are widely used to quantify the flow of water and nutrients in agricultural ecosystems and they have become important tools in the effort to address the twin challenges of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving agricultural sustainability. Model parameters require careful calibration, as they affect the simulated processes and outputs. Sensitivity analysis (SA) is commonly used to quantify the impacts of parameters on outputs, and guide the calibration process. Here we demonstrate a systematic approach for SA, which assures that (1) the role of time-dependency in the sensitivity indices is considered and (2) the SA is not biased by the edapho-climatic conditions at individual sites. Demonstrating this approach, we examine the parametric sensitivity of an advanced agroecosystem model (Landscape-DNDC) using a framework that is based on (1) the Sobol SA method, (2) model simulations at three UK arable sites and (3) the grouping of the model's parameters according to the processes they affect. The findings of this research identify the parameters and processes that should be carefully examined in order to minimise the impact of parametric uncertainty on model outputs. We show that a limited number of parameters are responsible for a large part of the sensitivity of model outputs. The description of soil microbial dynamics is identified as a key source of output sensitivity. Also, we show that individual management activities can significantly affect the time-dependency of the parametric sensitivity indices for certain model outputs.

AB - Process-based agroecosystem biogeochemistry models are widely used to quantify the flow of water and nutrients in agricultural ecosystems and they have become important tools in the effort to address the twin challenges of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and improving agricultural sustainability. Model parameters require careful calibration, as they affect the simulated processes and outputs. Sensitivity analysis (SA) is commonly used to quantify the impacts of parameters on outputs, and guide the calibration process. Here we demonstrate a systematic approach for SA, which assures that (1) the role of time-dependency in the sensitivity indices is considered and (2) the SA is not biased by the edapho-climatic conditions at individual sites. Demonstrating this approach, we examine the parametric sensitivity of an advanced agroecosystem model (Landscape-DNDC) using a framework that is based on (1) the Sobol SA method, (2) model simulations at three UK arable sites and (3) the grouping of the model's parameters according to the processes they affect. The findings of this research identify the parameters and processes that should be carefully examined in order to minimise the impact of parametric uncertainty on model outputs. We show that a limited number of parameters are responsible for a large part of the sensitivity of model outputs. The description of soil microbial dynamics is identified as a key source of output sensitivity. Also, we show that individual management activities can significantly affect the time-dependency of the parametric sensitivity indices for certain model outputs.

KW - Ecosystem modelling

KW - Landscape-DNDC

KW - Sensitivity analysis

KW - Soil biogeochemistry

U2 - 10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2017.12.009

DO - 10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2017.12.009

M3 - Article

VL - 368

SP - 344

EP - 356

JO - Ecological Modelling

JF - Ecological Modelling

SN - 0304-3800

ER -