Development of a fixed list of terms for the Qualitative Behavioural Assessment of shelter dogs

Laura Arena*, Françoise Wemelsfelder, Stefano Messori, Nicola Ferri, Shanis Barnard

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The shelter environment may have a severe impact on the dogs' quality of life, and there is thus a need to develop valid tools to assess their welfare. These tools should be sensitive not only to the animals' physical health but also to their mental health, including the assessment of positive and negative emotions. Qualitative Behaviour Assessment (QBA) is a 'whole animal' measure that captures the expressive quality of an animal's demeanour, using descriptive terms such as 'relaxed', 'anxious', and 'playful'. In this study, for the first time, we developed and tested a fixed-list of qualitative QBA terms for application to kennelled dogs. A list of 20 QBA terms was developed based on literature search and an expert opinion survey. Inter-observer reliability was investigated by asking 11 observers to use these terms to score 13 video clips of kennelled dogs. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was used to extract four main dimensions explaining 70.9% of the total variation between clips. PC1 characterised curious/playful/excitable/sociable demeanour, PC2 ranged from comfortable/relaxed to anxious/nervous/stressed expression, PC3 described fearful demeanour, and PC4 characterised bored/depressed demeanour. Observers' agreement on the ranking of video clips on these four expressive dimensions was good (Kendall's W: 0.60-0.80). ANOVA showed a significant effect of observer on mean clip score on all PCs (p<0.05), due to few observers scoring differently from the rest of the group. Results indicate the potential of the proposed list of QBA terms for sheltered dogs to serve, in alignment with other measures, as a non-invasive assessment tool. However, the observer effect on mean PC scores points towards the need for adequate observer training, particularly in live scoring conditions. The QBA scoring tool can be integrated with existing welfare assessment protocols for shelter dogs and strengthen the power of those protocols to evaluate the animals' experience in shelters.

Original languageEnglish
Article numbere0212652
JournalPLoS ONE
Volume14
Issue number10
Early online date4 Oct 2019
DOIs
Publication statusFirst published - 4 Oct 2019

Fingerprint

Animals
Surgical Instruments
Dogs
dogs
Health
animals
Analysis of variance (ANOVA)
mental health
Principal component analysis
expert opinion
Expert Testimony
emotions
Principal Component Analysis
quality of life
Analysis of Variance
Mental Health
Emotions
principal component analysis
analysis of variance
Quality of Life

Keywords

  • Dogs
  • Emotions
  • Animal welfare
  • Animal behaviour
  • Principal component analysis
  • Research validity
  • Fear
  • Relaxation (psychology)

Cite this

Arena, Laura ; Wemelsfelder, Françoise ; Messori, Stefano ; Ferri, Nicola ; Barnard, Shanis. / Development of a fixed list of terms for the Qualitative Behavioural Assessment of shelter dogs. In: PLoS ONE. 2019 ; Vol. 14, No. 10.
@article{49ea1525f1b4420a820c9c639637a4a7,
title = "Development of a fixed list of terms for the Qualitative Behavioural Assessment of shelter dogs",
abstract = "The shelter environment may have a severe impact on the dogs' quality of life, and there is thus a need to develop valid tools to assess their welfare. These tools should be sensitive not only to the animals' physical health but also to their mental health, including the assessment of positive and negative emotions. Qualitative Behaviour Assessment (QBA) is a 'whole animal' measure that captures the expressive quality of an animal's demeanour, using descriptive terms such as 'relaxed', 'anxious', and 'playful'. In this study, for the first time, we developed and tested a fixed-list of qualitative QBA terms for application to kennelled dogs. A list of 20 QBA terms was developed based on literature search and an expert opinion survey. Inter-observer reliability was investigated by asking 11 observers to use these terms to score 13 video clips of kennelled dogs. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was used to extract four main dimensions explaining 70.9{\%} of the total variation between clips. PC1 characterised curious/playful/excitable/sociable demeanour, PC2 ranged from comfortable/relaxed to anxious/nervous/stressed expression, PC3 described fearful demeanour, and PC4 characterised bored/depressed demeanour. Observers' agreement on the ranking of video clips on these four expressive dimensions was good (Kendall's W: 0.60-0.80). ANOVA showed a significant effect of observer on mean clip score on all PCs (p<0.05), due to few observers scoring differently from the rest of the group. Results indicate the potential of the proposed list of QBA terms for sheltered dogs to serve, in alignment with other measures, as a non-invasive assessment tool. However, the observer effect on mean PC scores points towards the need for adequate observer training, particularly in live scoring conditions. The QBA scoring tool can be integrated with existing welfare assessment protocols for shelter dogs and strengthen the power of those protocols to evaluate the animals' experience in shelters.",
keywords = "Dogs, Emotions, Animal welfare, Animal behaviour, Principal component analysis, Research validity, Fear, Relaxation (psychology)",
author = "Laura Arena and Fran{\cc}oise Wemelsfelder and Stefano Messori and Nicola Ferri and Shanis Barnard",
year = "2019",
month = "10",
day = "4",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pone.0212652",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
journal = "PLoS ONE",
issn = "1932-6203",
publisher = "Public Library of Science",
number = "10",

}

Development of a fixed list of terms for the Qualitative Behavioural Assessment of shelter dogs. / Arena, Laura; Wemelsfelder, Françoise; Messori, Stefano; Ferri, Nicola; Barnard, Shanis.

In: PLoS ONE, Vol. 14, No. 10, e0212652, 04.10.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Development of a fixed list of terms for the Qualitative Behavioural Assessment of shelter dogs

AU - Arena, Laura

AU - Wemelsfelder, Françoise

AU - Messori, Stefano

AU - Ferri, Nicola

AU - Barnard, Shanis

PY - 2019/10/4

Y1 - 2019/10/4

N2 - The shelter environment may have a severe impact on the dogs' quality of life, and there is thus a need to develop valid tools to assess their welfare. These tools should be sensitive not only to the animals' physical health but also to their mental health, including the assessment of positive and negative emotions. Qualitative Behaviour Assessment (QBA) is a 'whole animal' measure that captures the expressive quality of an animal's demeanour, using descriptive terms such as 'relaxed', 'anxious', and 'playful'. In this study, for the first time, we developed and tested a fixed-list of qualitative QBA terms for application to kennelled dogs. A list of 20 QBA terms was developed based on literature search and an expert opinion survey. Inter-observer reliability was investigated by asking 11 observers to use these terms to score 13 video clips of kennelled dogs. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was used to extract four main dimensions explaining 70.9% of the total variation between clips. PC1 characterised curious/playful/excitable/sociable demeanour, PC2 ranged from comfortable/relaxed to anxious/nervous/stressed expression, PC3 described fearful demeanour, and PC4 characterised bored/depressed demeanour. Observers' agreement on the ranking of video clips on these four expressive dimensions was good (Kendall's W: 0.60-0.80). ANOVA showed a significant effect of observer on mean clip score on all PCs (p<0.05), due to few observers scoring differently from the rest of the group. Results indicate the potential of the proposed list of QBA terms for sheltered dogs to serve, in alignment with other measures, as a non-invasive assessment tool. However, the observer effect on mean PC scores points towards the need for adequate observer training, particularly in live scoring conditions. The QBA scoring tool can be integrated with existing welfare assessment protocols for shelter dogs and strengthen the power of those protocols to evaluate the animals' experience in shelters.

AB - The shelter environment may have a severe impact on the dogs' quality of life, and there is thus a need to develop valid tools to assess their welfare. These tools should be sensitive not only to the animals' physical health but also to their mental health, including the assessment of positive and negative emotions. Qualitative Behaviour Assessment (QBA) is a 'whole animal' measure that captures the expressive quality of an animal's demeanour, using descriptive terms such as 'relaxed', 'anxious', and 'playful'. In this study, for the first time, we developed and tested a fixed-list of qualitative QBA terms for application to kennelled dogs. A list of 20 QBA terms was developed based on literature search and an expert opinion survey. Inter-observer reliability was investigated by asking 11 observers to use these terms to score 13 video clips of kennelled dogs. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was used to extract four main dimensions explaining 70.9% of the total variation between clips. PC1 characterised curious/playful/excitable/sociable demeanour, PC2 ranged from comfortable/relaxed to anxious/nervous/stressed expression, PC3 described fearful demeanour, and PC4 characterised bored/depressed demeanour. Observers' agreement on the ranking of video clips on these four expressive dimensions was good (Kendall's W: 0.60-0.80). ANOVA showed a significant effect of observer on mean clip score on all PCs (p<0.05), due to few observers scoring differently from the rest of the group. Results indicate the potential of the proposed list of QBA terms for sheltered dogs to serve, in alignment with other measures, as a non-invasive assessment tool. However, the observer effect on mean PC scores points towards the need for adequate observer training, particularly in live scoring conditions. The QBA scoring tool can be integrated with existing welfare assessment protocols for shelter dogs and strengthen the power of those protocols to evaluate the animals' experience in shelters.

KW - Dogs

KW - Emotions

KW - Animal welfare

KW - Animal behaviour

KW - Principal component analysis

KW - Research validity

KW - Fear

KW - Relaxation (psychology)

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85072928849&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pone.0212652

DO - 10.1371/journal.pone.0212652

M3 - Article

C2 - 31584954

AN - SCOPUS:85072928849

VL - 14

JO - PLoS ONE

JF - PLoS ONE

SN - 1932-6203

IS - 10

M1 - e0212652

ER -