Effects of changing cow production and fitness traits on profit and greenhouse gas emissions of UK dairy systems

MJ Bell, PC Garnsworthy, AW Stott, JE Pryce

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)
11 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The aim of the present study was to compare the effect of changing a range of biological traits on farm profit and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (expressed as carbon dioxide equivalent, CO2-eq.) in the UK dairy cow population. AMarkov chain approach was used to describe the steady-state herd structure of the average milk-recorded UK dairy herd, aswell as to estimate the CO2-eq. emissions per cow, and per kilogram of milk solids (MS). Effects of changing each herd production and fitness trait by one unit (e.g. 1 kg milk; 1% mastitis incidence) were assessed, with derived values for change in profit (economic values) being used in a multi-trait selection index. Of the traits studied, an increase in survival and reductions in milk volume, live weight, residual feed intake, somatic cell count, mastitis incidence, lameness incidence and calving interval were traits that would be both profitable and reduce CO2-eq. emissions per cow and per kg MS of a dairy herd. A multi-trait selection index was used to estimate the annual response in production and fitness traits and the economic response, with an estimate of annual profit per cow from selection on multiple traits. Milk volume, milk fat and protein yield, live weight, survival and dry matter intake were estimated to increase each year and body condition score, residual feed intake, somatic cell count, mastitis incidence, lameness incidence and calving interval were estimated to decrease, with selection on these traits estimated to result in an annual increase of 1% per year in GHG emissions per cow, but a reduction of 0·9% per unit product. Improved efficiencies of production associated with a reduction in milk volume (and increasing fat and protein content), live weight and feed intake (gross and metabolic efficiency, respectively), and increase in health, fertility and overall survival will increase farm annual profit of UK dairy systems and reduce their environmental impact.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)138 - 151
Number of pages14
JournalJournal of Agricultural Science
Volume153
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPrint publication - 2014

Fingerprint

greenhouse gas emissions
profits and margins
dairies
cows
milk
incidence
carbon dioxide
multiple trait selection
mastitis
feed intake
calving interval
selection index
dairy herds
lameness
body weight
herds
live feeds
farms
gas emissions
milk protein yield

Bibliographical note

1023392
WP4.2

Keywords

  • Dairy cows
  • Greenhouse gas emissions
  • Production systems
  • Profitability

Cite this

Bell, MJ ; Garnsworthy, PC ; Stott, AW ; Pryce, JE. / Effects of changing cow production and fitness traits on profit and greenhouse gas emissions of UK dairy systems. In: Journal of Agricultural Science. 2014 ; Vol. 153, No. 1. pp. 138 - 151.
@article{c09903ea081d4cf09dc4fb106701d599,
title = "Effects of changing cow production and fitness traits on profit and greenhouse gas emissions of UK dairy systems",
abstract = "The aim of the present study was to compare the effect of changing a range of biological traits on farm profit and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (expressed as carbon dioxide equivalent, CO2-eq.) in the UK dairy cow population. AMarkov chain approach was used to describe the steady-state herd structure of the average milk-recorded UK dairy herd, aswell as to estimate the CO2-eq. emissions per cow, and per kilogram of milk solids (MS). Effects of changing each herd production and fitness trait by one unit (e.g. 1 kg milk; 1{\%} mastitis incidence) were assessed, with derived values for change in profit (economic values) being used in a multi-trait selection index. Of the traits studied, an increase in survival and reductions in milk volume, live weight, residual feed intake, somatic cell count, mastitis incidence, lameness incidence and calving interval were traits that would be both profitable and reduce CO2-eq. emissions per cow and per kg MS of a dairy herd. A multi-trait selection index was used to estimate the annual response in production and fitness traits and the economic response, with an estimate of annual profit per cow from selection on multiple traits. Milk volume, milk fat and protein yield, live weight, survival and dry matter intake were estimated to increase each year and body condition score, residual feed intake, somatic cell count, mastitis incidence, lameness incidence and calving interval were estimated to decrease, with selection on these traits estimated to result in an annual increase of 1{\%} per year in GHG emissions per cow, but a reduction of 0·9{\%} per unit product. Improved efficiencies of production associated with a reduction in milk volume (and increasing fat and protein content), live weight and feed intake (gross and metabolic efficiency, respectively), and increase in health, fertility and overall survival will increase farm annual profit of UK dairy systems and reduce their environmental impact.",
keywords = "Dairy cows, Greenhouse gas emissions, Production systems, Profitability",
author = "MJ Bell and PC Garnsworthy and AW Stott and JE Pryce",
note = "1023392 WP4.2",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1017/S0021859614000847",
language = "English",
volume = "153",
pages = "138 -- 151",
journal = "Journal of Agricultural Science",
issn = "0021-8596",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
number = "1",

}

Effects of changing cow production and fitness traits on profit and greenhouse gas emissions of UK dairy systems. / Bell, MJ; Garnsworthy, PC; Stott, AW; Pryce, JE.

In: Journal of Agricultural Science, Vol. 153, No. 1, 2014, p. 138 - 151.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effects of changing cow production and fitness traits on profit and greenhouse gas emissions of UK dairy systems

AU - Bell, MJ

AU - Garnsworthy, PC

AU - Stott, AW

AU - Pryce, JE

N1 - 1023392 WP4.2

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - The aim of the present study was to compare the effect of changing a range of biological traits on farm profit and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (expressed as carbon dioxide equivalent, CO2-eq.) in the UK dairy cow population. AMarkov chain approach was used to describe the steady-state herd structure of the average milk-recorded UK dairy herd, aswell as to estimate the CO2-eq. emissions per cow, and per kilogram of milk solids (MS). Effects of changing each herd production and fitness trait by one unit (e.g. 1 kg milk; 1% mastitis incidence) were assessed, with derived values for change in profit (economic values) being used in a multi-trait selection index. Of the traits studied, an increase in survival and reductions in milk volume, live weight, residual feed intake, somatic cell count, mastitis incidence, lameness incidence and calving interval were traits that would be both profitable and reduce CO2-eq. emissions per cow and per kg MS of a dairy herd. A multi-trait selection index was used to estimate the annual response in production and fitness traits and the economic response, with an estimate of annual profit per cow from selection on multiple traits. Milk volume, milk fat and protein yield, live weight, survival and dry matter intake were estimated to increase each year and body condition score, residual feed intake, somatic cell count, mastitis incidence, lameness incidence and calving interval were estimated to decrease, with selection on these traits estimated to result in an annual increase of 1% per year in GHG emissions per cow, but a reduction of 0·9% per unit product. Improved efficiencies of production associated with a reduction in milk volume (and increasing fat and protein content), live weight and feed intake (gross and metabolic efficiency, respectively), and increase in health, fertility and overall survival will increase farm annual profit of UK dairy systems and reduce their environmental impact.

AB - The aim of the present study was to compare the effect of changing a range of biological traits on farm profit and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions (expressed as carbon dioxide equivalent, CO2-eq.) in the UK dairy cow population. AMarkov chain approach was used to describe the steady-state herd structure of the average milk-recorded UK dairy herd, aswell as to estimate the CO2-eq. emissions per cow, and per kilogram of milk solids (MS). Effects of changing each herd production and fitness trait by one unit (e.g. 1 kg milk; 1% mastitis incidence) were assessed, with derived values for change in profit (economic values) being used in a multi-trait selection index. Of the traits studied, an increase in survival and reductions in milk volume, live weight, residual feed intake, somatic cell count, mastitis incidence, lameness incidence and calving interval were traits that would be both profitable and reduce CO2-eq. emissions per cow and per kg MS of a dairy herd. A multi-trait selection index was used to estimate the annual response in production and fitness traits and the economic response, with an estimate of annual profit per cow from selection on multiple traits. Milk volume, milk fat and protein yield, live weight, survival and dry matter intake were estimated to increase each year and body condition score, residual feed intake, somatic cell count, mastitis incidence, lameness incidence and calving interval were estimated to decrease, with selection on these traits estimated to result in an annual increase of 1% per year in GHG emissions per cow, but a reduction of 0·9% per unit product. Improved efficiencies of production associated with a reduction in milk volume (and increasing fat and protein content), live weight and feed intake (gross and metabolic efficiency, respectively), and increase in health, fertility and overall survival will increase farm annual profit of UK dairy systems and reduce their environmental impact.

KW - Dairy cows

KW - Greenhouse gas emissions

KW - Production systems

KW - Profitability

U2 - 10.1017/S0021859614000847

DO - 10.1017/S0021859614000847

M3 - Article

VL - 153

SP - 138

EP - 151

JO - Journal of Agricultural Science

JF - Journal of Agricultural Science

SN - 0021-8596

IS - 1

ER -