Playful pigs: early life play-fighting experience influences later life contest dynamics

Jennifer E Weller, I Camerlink, SP Turner, M Farish, G Arnott

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Animal contests are costly and predicted to be won by the individual with the higher resource-holding potential (RHP). Weight is often used a proxy for RHP; however, victory does not always go to the heaviest competitor, indicating that other traits may also contribute to RHP. Here we investigated the effect of preweaning play-fighting experience on postweaning contest behaviour in the domestic pig, Sus scrofa. We predicted that individuals that played more would win contests later in life. Play-fighting experience was also predicted to influence contest escalation behaviour, on both an individual and a dyadic level. Lastly, a pre-established framework and eight contest cost measures were used to establish whether competing individuals gather/use information regarding play-fighting experience as part of an assessment strategy. Play-fighting experience was recorded for socialized and control litters before weaning and contests were staged between unfamiliar pigs of the same treatment after weaning. Controlling for competitor weight difference revealed that increased play-fighting experience was linked to contest success in females, while the opposite pattern was found in males. Play-fighting experience did not influence which individual within the dyad escalated contest behaviour, but dyads containing more experienced losers were more likely to perform a stage of nondamaging aggression. When we used skin lesions in losers as a measure of contest cost, we found evidence for the role of play-fighting experience in a novel mutual assessment strategy in socialized dyads, whereas control dyads performed opponent-only assessment. We suggest that while assessments of RHP can be made using a physical correlate of play-fighting experience (such as skilfulness), early life socialization is required for individuals to gain an understanding of their own RHP.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)269-279
Number of pages11
JournalAnimal Behaviour
Volume158
Early online date25 Oct 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPrint publication - Dec 2019

Fingerprint

fighting
pig
swine
weaning
Sus scrofa
skin lesions
resource
aggression
animals
cost
lesion
skin
litter
animal

Keywords

  • Aggression
  • Assessment
  • Contest
  • Fighting ability
  • Pig
  • Play
  • Resource-holding potential

Cite this

Weller, Jennifer E ; Camerlink, I ; Turner, SP ; Farish, M ; Arnott, G. / Playful pigs: early life play-fighting experience influences later life contest dynamics. In: Animal Behaviour. 2019 ; Vol. 158. pp. 269-279.
@article{d6d657ef64a346618be70f301318d6f0,
title = "Playful pigs: early life play-fighting experience influences later life contest dynamics",
abstract = "Animal contests are costly and predicted to be won by the individual with the higher resource-holding potential (RHP). Weight is often used a proxy for RHP; however, victory does not always go to the heaviest competitor, indicating that other traits may also contribute to RHP. Here we investigated the effect of preweaning play-fighting experience on postweaning contest behaviour in the domestic pig, Sus scrofa. We predicted that individuals that played more would win contests later in life. Play-fighting experience was also predicted to influence contest escalation behaviour, on both an individual and a dyadic level. Lastly, a pre-established framework and eight contest cost measures were used to establish whether competing individuals gather/use information regarding play-fighting experience as part of an assessment strategy. Play-fighting experience was recorded for socialized and control litters before weaning and contests were staged between unfamiliar pigs of the same treatment after weaning. Controlling for competitor weight difference revealed that increased play-fighting experience was linked to contest success in females, while the opposite pattern was found in males. Play-fighting experience did not influence which individual within the dyad escalated contest behaviour, but dyads containing more experienced losers were more likely to perform a stage of nondamaging aggression. When we used skin lesions in losers as a measure of contest cost, we found evidence for the role of play-fighting experience in a novel mutual assessment strategy in socialized dyads, whereas control dyads performed opponent-only assessment. We suggest that while assessments of RHP can be made using a physical correlate of play-fighting experience (such as skilfulness), early life socialization is required for individuals to gain an understanding of their own RHP.",
keywords = "Aggression, Assessment, Contest, Fighting ability, Pig, Play, Resource-holding potential",
author = "Weller, {Jennifer E} and I Camerlink and SP Turner and M Farish and G Arnott",
year = "2019",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1016/j.anbehav.2019.09.019",
language = "English",
volume = "158",
pages = "269--279",
journal = "Animal Behaviour",
issn = "0003-3472",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Playful pigs: early life play-fighting experience influences later life contest dynamics. / Weller, Jennifer E; Camerlink, I; Turner, SP; Farish, M; Arnott, G.

In: Animal Behaviour, Vol. 158, 12.2019, p. 269-279.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Playful pigs: early life play-fighting experience influences later life contest dynamics

AU - Weller, Jennifer E

AU - Camerlink, I

AU - Turner, SP

AU - Farish, M

AU - Arnott, G

PY - 2019/12

Y1 - 2019/12

N2 - Animal contests are costly and predicted to be won by the individual with the higher resource-holding potential (RHP). Weight is often used a proxy for RHP; however, victory does not always go to the heaviest competitor, indicating that other traits may also contribute to RHP. Here we investigated the effect of preweaning play-fighting experience on postweaning contest behaviour in the domestic pig, Sus scrofa. We predicted that individuals that played more would win contests later in life. Play-fighting experience was also predicted to influence contest escalation behaviour, on both an individual and a dyadic level. Lastly, a pre-established framework and eight contest cost measures were used to establish whether competing individuals gather/use information regarding play-fighting experience as part of an assessment strategy. Play-fighting experience was recorded for socialized and control litters before weaning and contests were staged between unfamiliar pigs of the same treatment after weaning. Controlling for competitor weight difference revealed that increased play-fighting experience was linked to contest success in females, while the opposite pattern was found in males. Play-fighting experience did not influence which individual within the dyad escalated contest behaviour, but dyads containing more experienced losers were more likely to perform a stage of nondamaging aggression. When we used skin lesions in losers as a measure of contest cost, we found evidence for the role of play-fighting experience in a novel mutual assessment strategy in socialized dyads, whereas control dyads performed opponent-only assessment. We suggest that while assessments of RHP can be made using a physical correlate of play-fighting experience (such as skilfulness), early life socialization is required for individuals to gain an understanding of their own RHP.

AB - Animal contests are costly and predicted to be won by the individual with the higher resource-holding potential (RHP). Weight is often used a proxy for RHP; however, victory does not always go to the heaviest competitor, indicating that other traits may also contribute to RHP. Here we investigated the effect of preweaning play-fighting experience on postweaning contest behaviour in the domestic pig, Sus scrofa. We predicted that individuals that played more would win contests later in life. Play-fighting experience was also predicted to influence contest escalation behaviour, on both an individual and a dyadic level. Lastly, a pre-established framework and eight contest cost measures were used to establish whether competing individuals gather/use information regarding play-fighting experience as part of an assessment strategy. Play-fighting experience was recorded for socialized and control litters before weaning and contests were staged between unfamiliar pigs of the same treatment after weaning. Controlling for competitor weight difference revealed that increased play-fighting experience was linked to contest success in females, while the opposite pattern was found in males. Play-fighting experience did not influence which individual within the dyad escalated contest behaviour, but dyads containing more experienced losers were more likely to perform a stage of nondamaging aggression. When we used skin lesions in losers as a measure of contest cost, we found evidence for the role of play-fighting experience in a novel mutual assessment strategy in socialized dyads, whereas control dyads performed opponent-only assessment. We suggest that while assessments of RHP can be made using a physical correlate of play-fighting experience (such as skilfulness), early life socialization is required for individuals to gain an understanding of their own RHP.

KW - Aggression

KW - Assessment

KW - Contest

KW - Fighting ability

KW - Pig

KW - Play

KW - Resource-holding potential

U2 - 10.1016/j.anbehav.2019.09.019

DO - 10.1016/j.anbehav.2019.09.019

M3 - Article

VL - 158

SP - 269

EP - 279

JO - Animal Behaviour

JF - Animal Behaviour

SN - 0003-3472

ER -