Regional trends in Scottish advisory soil acidity and phosphorus results: significance of management history, land use and soil attributes

AC Edwards, AH Sinclair, M Coull, W Crooks, RM Rees, DG Lumsdon

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Four geographically distinct regions of Scotland are used to describe temporal and spatial trends in soil phosphorus (P) using ca. 180 000 routine advisory samples which included information on previous and next crop. Regional differences in Modified Morgan’s extractable P concentrations exist primarily in response to differences in land use and particularly the greater role of livestock in the west compared to arable cropping in the east. No obvious or consistent temporal trend in extractable P was apparent, but a very wide range of soil properties and extractable P concentrations was evident. The current (since 2010) target soil P status is moderate (M) for cereal-based arable rotations and the upper half of moderate (M+) for rotations with potatoes, and more than half the samples fell into this range (with 40% M ). Some ca. 30% of samples fell below this, while 14% had high or very high P status, most noticeably where the previous crop was either potatoes, vegetables or berries. Half (ca. 13 000) of the samples with a low soil P status also had a below optimum pH. An apparent contradiction between the regularly reported long-term declines in agricultural P surplus not being matched by a drop in extractable soil P status is discussed. This ‘lag effect’ means many Scottish agricultural soils have the capability to buffer change in extractable soil P. We make the first attempt to link advisory P data with information from the National Soil Database of Scotland and explore the value of introducing ‘soil type’ into the P fertilizer recommendation system.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)44 - 53
Number of pages10
JournalSoil Use and Management
Volume32 Supp. S1
DOIs
Publication statusFirst published - 2016

Fingerprint

acidity
phosphorus
land use
history
soil
potato
crop
cereal
vegetable
trend
attribute
soil type
cropping practice
livestock
soil property
fertilizer

Bibliographical note

1023321

Keywords

  • Acidity
  • Buffer capacity
  • Cropping history
  • Fertilizer recommendation
  • Phosphorus
  • Soil type

Cite this

@article{675e49588c9048319169670e23974e65,
title = "Regional trends in Scottish advisory soil acidity and phosphorus results: significance of management history, land use and soil attributes",
abstract = "Four geographically distinct regions of Scotland are used to describe temporal and spatial trends in soil phosphorus (P) using ca. 180 000 routine advisory samples which included information on previous and next crop. Regional differences in Modified Morgan’s extractable P concentrations exist primarily in response to differences in land use and particularly the greater role of livestock in the west compared to arable cropping in the east. No obvious or consistent temporal trend in extractable P was apparent, but a very wide range of soil properties and extractable P concentrations was evident. The current (since 2010) target soil P status is moderate (M) for cereal-based arable rotations and the upper half of moderate (M+) for rotations with potatoes, and more than half the samples fell into this range (with 40{\%} M ). Some ca. 30{\%} of samples fell below this, while 14{\%} had high or very high P status, most noticeably where the previous crop was either potatoes, vegetables or berries. Half (ca. 13 000) of the samples with a low soil P status also had a below optimum pH. An apparent contradiction between the regularly reported long-term declines in agricultural P surplus not being matched by a drop in extractable soil P status is discussed. This ‘lag effect’ means many Scottish agricultural soils have the capability to buffer change in extractable soil P. We make the first attempt to link advisory P data with information from the National Soil Database of Scotland and explore the value of introducing ‘soil type’ into the P fertilizer recommendation system.",
keywords = "Acidity, Buffer capacity, Cropping history, Fertilizer recommendation, Phosphorus, Soil type",
author = "AC Edwards and AH Sinclair and M Coull and W Crooks and RM Rees and DG Lumsdon",
note = "1023321",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1111/sum.12221",
language = "English",
volume = "32 Supp. S1",
pages = "44 -- 53",
journal = "Soil Use and Management",
issn = "0266-0032",
publisher = "Wiley",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Regional trends in Scottish advisory soil acidity and phosphorus results: significance of management history, land use and soil attributes

AU - Edwards, AC

AU - Sinclair, AH

AU - Coull, M

AU - Crooks, W

AU - Rees, RM

AU - Lumsdon, DG

N1 - 1023321

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - Four geographically distinct regions of Scotland are used to describe temporal and spatial trends in soil phosphorus (P) using ca. 180 000 routine advisory samples which included information on previous and next crop. Regional differences in Modified Morgan’s extractable P concentrations exist primarily in response to differences in land use and particularly the greater role of livestock in the west compared to arable cropping in the east. No obvious or consistent temporal trend in extractable P was apparent, but a very wide range of soil properties and extractable P concentrations was evident. The current (since 2010) target soil P status is moderate (M) for cereal-based arable rotations and the upper half of moderate (M+) for rotations with potatoes, and more than half the samples fell into this range (with 40% M ). Some ca. 30% of samples fell below this, while 14% had high or very high P status, most noticeably where the previous crop was either potatoes, vegetables or berries. Half (ca. 13 000) of the samples with a low soil P status also had a below optimum pH. An apparent contradiction between the regularly reported long-term declines in agricultural P surplus not being matched by a drop in extractable soil P status is discussed. This ‘lag effect’ means many Scottish agricultural soils have the capability to buffer change in extractable soil P. We make the first attempt to link advisory P data with information from the National Soil Database of Scotland and explore the value of introducing ‘soil type’ into the P fertilizer recommendation system.

AB - Four geographically distinct regions of Scotland are used to describe temporal and spatial trends in soil phosphorus (P) using ca. 180 000 routine advisory samples which included information on previous and next crop. Regional differences in Modified Morgan’s extractable P concentrations exist primarily in response to differences in land use and particularly the greater role of livestock in the west compared to arable cropping in the east. No obvious or consistent temporal trend in extractable P was apparent, but a very wide range of soil properties and extractable P concentrations was evident. The current (since 2010) target soil P status is moderate (M) for cereal-based arable rotations and the upper half of moderate (M+) for rotations with potatoes, and more than half the samples fell into this range (with 40% M ). Some ca. 30% of samples fell below this, while 14% had high or very high P status, most noticeably where the previous crop was either potatoes, vegetables or berries. Half (ca. 13 000) of the samples with a low soil P status also had a below optimum pH. An apparent contradiction between the regularly reported long-term declines in agricultural P surplus not being matched by a drop in extractable soil P status is discussed. This ‘lag effect’ means many Scottish agricultural soils have the capability to buffer change in extractable soil P. We make the first attempt to link advisory P data with information from the National Soil Database of Scotland and explore the value of introducing ‘soil type’ into the P fertilizer recommendation system.

KW - Acidity

KW - Buffer capacity

KW - Cropping history

KW - Fertilizer recommendation

KW - Phosphorus

KW - Soil type

U2 - 10.1111/sum.12221

DO - 10.1111/sum.12221

M3 - Article

VL - 32 Supp. S1

SP - 44

EP - 53

JO - Soil Use and Management

JF - Soil Use and Management

SN - 0266-0032

ER -